Workington Comets
Edinburgh Monarchs
Premier Trophy
41
34
Saturday 1st April 2006
Derwent Park

Another 12-heater started our Premier Trophy campaign with a 41-34 loss at Workington.

During the early part of the evening it did look as though we might go down more heavily, but we staged a fightback and at the time of the abandonment we felt reasonably optimistic that we wouldn't lose any ground over the final three heats.

It wasn't a solid 7-man effort though, and that is what we really need away from home. William had a very disappointing night and Henrik struggled too, though it seemed reasonable to think that Derwent Park would be more to his liking than Armadale where he made a fair debut the night before.

But we can have nothing but praise for Rusty's terrific riding, and Derek's brave battling, while Theo and Matthew eventually got organised to turn in some good rides.

With rain forecast we sped straight into heat one, or we would have done if Paul Thorp hadn't come out without his dirt deflector and suffered a 2-minute exclusion. Not only that but Piszcz blew a motor on the line and was maybe fortunate that the referee was slow putting on the second two minutes.

In spite of these problems the Comets were away to a quick start (Collins in for Thorp), and only when Aidan ran into difficulties on the last lap did Henrik nip through for a second place. That was his only success of the night.

Was Derek thinking back three years when he was coming out of the second bend in heat 2? Only he knows, but an inside move by Derbyshire was not unlike the incident in which Derek broke his leg back then.

However having avoided contact Derek fought back to pass Derbyshire, and then take advantage of further gremlins for Collins to win the heat.

We were swamped 5-1 in heat 3, with William keeping up his average of one engine failure per match.

Of course we knew Rusty would improve things, and he did as he took a flying win over Garry Stead with Derek third.

Theo made a good start in heat 5 but got caught coming out of the second bend as Wright and Hawkins took their second 5-1. It was a disappointing start to the meeting for the captain.

Rusty won again in heat 6 with a very forceful second bend which seemed to unsettle Piszcz, who only just beat Sean for third.

Matthew and William had looked too slow in heat 3, and certainly did again in heat 7 as Stead and Collins easily took 5 points.

Although he hadn't done much, we had no choice but to give Theo the black-and-white hat for heat 8, and he responded with a good start and a flying win. Derek (who scored in every ride) this time beat Collins. So a 7-2 cut the gap to 7 points.

Rusty gated badly in heat 9 behind Wright and Hawkins, but he soon went round Hawkins to prevent a third 5-1 for that pair. There was no catching Wright though.

Heat 10 was a remarkable heat. Race leader Tomasz Piszcz was hounded all the way by Matthew, going far better than in his earlier rides, and on the last lap our Aussie squeezed through for a great win. Meanwhile Derek was getting the better of Thorp, blocking the attempts of the more experienced man to come through on the inside.

It was the best heat of the match, and the next one was a goodie too. Theo showed he had learnt about that Workington second bend with a forceful exit to pass Stead, and on a track now starting to get damp he recorded a fine win.

We all knew that the next heat had to be completed to bring a result. It was a tight first turn with Derek and Matthew holding their ground against Hawkins and Collins, but Mathew came down on the outside. In the rerun our pair kept Aidan at the back, and after that the rain (which seems to know when heat 12 comes) came pelting down driven by a cold wind. The end, again.

Workington is a track where we won last year although it has to be conceded that Dame Fortune smiled on us a bit that night. Saturday night's match sees us face a totally different Comets side from last year.

Gone (for the present at least) is Carl Stonehewer (injured), Kauko Nieminen (to Glasgow), Kevin Little (to Redcar) and Scott Robson (retired). In come the former Hull top two of Paul Thorp and Garry Stead together with Ritchie Hawkins. Also returning is Aidan Collins to join James Wright and Tomas Piszcz from last year with Lee Derbyshire filling the remaining reserve berth.

The Comets have at least completed one home match in the Premier Trophy when they edged out Sheffield by five points two weeks ago. It was none too convincing though as they had held a 14 point lead until Sheffield staged a revival which in the final analysis just fell a bit short. It would seem then that the Comets, one of the teams expected to do well this year, are not quite as invincible as perhaps many thought if this first match is anything to go by. One of their big problems is the inconsistent form of Paul Thorp riding at number 1 as Carl Stonehewer's replacement. When Paul gates he's as good as anyone in the league but he is less impressive when he fails to gate. At Newcastle he even finished behind Adam McKinna in one race on a wet track which, with all due respect to Adam, he should not have. This was even more galling for the Comets as they only went down by one point in a 47-46 thriller.

Having said that it can not be denied that the Comets have some very real strengths none more so than at number 2 where Tomas Piszcz, on a very low average, looks a real find. With Ritchie Hawkins settling in well and Aidan Collins immediately showing his value as the 'A' reserve with some big scores there is a very solid look to the Workington side this year with only Lee Derbyshire as the 'C' reserve likely to struggle.

For the Monarchs to repeat their success of last year the team will need to slip into top gear very quickly. This will be difficult given their lack of activity over the last two weeks. Of course, Rusty Harrison is no stranger to the track and should provide the top end scoring needed but all eyes will be on how Henrik Moller and reserves Derek Sneddon and Sean Stoddart perform. Derek suffered his horrendous broken femur accident at this track so will need to banish the memories this match might evoke.

The key to the result may well lie in the performances of these three in particular but it is perhaps a bit early in the season to expect too much from them until they have raced a few matches. Overall a win for the home side looks odds-on and Edinburgh will do well to hit the 40 point mark to give themselves a chance of the bonus point at Armadale in the return match.